Demeaning prisoners is not rehabilitative.


With respect of the plan of a Prison …I had heard of a benevolent society in England which had been indulged by the government in an experiment of the effect of labor in solitary confinement on some of their criminals, which experiment had succeeded beyond expectation …This I sent to the Directors instead of a plan of a common prison, in the hope that it would suggest the idea of labor in solitary confinement instead of that on the public works … In 1796 … They adopted solitary, instead of public labor, established a gradation in the duration of the confinement …

Source: Autobiography, 1821 

Patrick Lee’s Explanation

Compassionate leaders seek rehabilitation in punishment.
Jefferson’s original revision of the criminal code reduced the number of capital offenses from several dozen to just two, for murder and treason. Lesser crimes received hard labor, often on public works building roads and canals. Experience, though, showed that prisoners being “exhibited as a public spectacle, with shaved heads and mean clothing, working on the high roads” didn’t rehabilitate. Instead, it produced the “most desperate & hardened depravity of morals and character.” It made men worse, not better.

Borrowing from successful experiments in Europe, he proposed “labor in … solitary confinement.” (This must mean labor within the prison complex rather than in public, and not solitary confinement as we understand it today.) Virginia built a “Penitentiary” instead of “a common prison” with this idea in mind. Fifteen years later, Virginia abandoned hard public labor for prisoners.

The last line in this excerpt implies a gradual improvement in an inmate’s work status through the course of his confinement.

“ …our Institute Planning Committee was showered with accolades
for its wisdom
and good judgment in inviting
William Clark of the famous Lewis and Clark team…”
Wisconsin Society of Land Surveyors
Leaders William Clark and Daniel Boone will inspire your audience, too!
Invite them to speak. Call 573-657-2739


The Moral Liberal Thomas Jefferson Editor, Patrick Lee, is a professional speaker, actor and writer. Since 1990, he has inspired, entertained and educated audiences from Maine to Hawaii with his authentic, first person leadership presentations as President Thomas Jefferson, Frontiersman Daniel Boone, and Lewis & Clark Co-Leader William Clark. He also appears as himself, The Hopeful Humorist™, with a program of motivational humor, patriotism and inspiration.

His business address is